Close Menu
    Trending
    • A High School Dropout Tackled Online Returns — Now Makes $500M
    • How a Futurama plotline led to a totally new math proof
    • Journey Guitarist Slams Bruce Springsteen as ‘Annoying, Bitter Old Man’ for Turning Concerts into Anti-Trump Political Rallies * The Gateway Pundit * by Cassandra MacDonald
    • ‘Health Issue’ Halts Harry Styles’ Brazil Concert
    • Murdered ex-UK minister Widdecombe was struck on head with hammer 21 times, court told
    • US appeals court overturns ruling that freed Columbia activist Mahdawi | Censorship News
    • The ‘Active 20-HR season leaders’ quiz
    • Burger King President Says GLP-1s Will Have ‘Impact’ on Industry
    Benjamin Franklin Institute
    Tuesday, July 21
    • Home
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Science
    • Technology
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • International
    Benjamin Franklin Institute
    Home»Opinions»Opinion | Breaking the Two-Party System
    Opinions

    Opinion | Breaking the Two-Party System

    Team_Benjamin Franklin InstituteBy Team_Benjamin Franklin InstituteMay 20, 2026No Comments3 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest Copy Link LinkedIn Tumblr Email VKontakte Telegram
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest Email Copy Link


    We are not a two-party system in America by accident. We are a two-party system in America by structure. And proportional representation, at least at the House level, might break that structure. So why is proportional representation friendlier to a multi-party system. Why would it break the two-party system compared to what we have now. Well, the reason we have the two-party system is not because Americans want just two parties. And you see, in poll after poll, Americans say, I’d like to have more choices, but the structure of single-winner elections is such that third parties become spoilers and wasted votes. So all of the energy concentrates in both of the major parties, because they essentially have a monopoly on opposition to each other, and there’s a lot of pressure to join one of the two teams. We also have a primary system, the primaries, where if you’re a dissenter, it’s better to run as a Democrat or a Republican. Like Bernie Sanders could have run as a third party. He’s not even a Democrat, but he’s going to run in the Democratic primary. Donald Trump ran as a Reform Party candidate the first time he ran for president. Then he realized, I can run as a Republican and I can control the Republican Party if I win. So under a proportional system, you don’t need to get 51 percent of the vote to represent a district. If it’s a five-member district, 20 percent. – And that allows —— – Would give you a seat. – Would give you a seat. And —— – So you could have a situation where you have the Republicans winning most votes, Democrats coming in second and a third party coming in third, and the third party has a seat in Congress as opposed to just made the Democrats lose. Right, exactly. You could, in theory, have five different parties winning a seat in a five-member district. So Donald Trump wins the Republican nomination in 2016. There is at that time, a fairly large faction of Republican voters who are dissatisfied with that choice. But, really, they are then offered a choice between, particularly at the House level, voting for Republicans, which is their party, or voting for the Democrats, on whom they disagree with on everything. Now, you could have imagined a Conservative Party emerging saying, “We’re the real conservatives. And we hold traditional Republican Party views on a bunch of different issues. And vote for us at the House level. And we’ll represent you in Congress and work with Republicans and Democrats as needed.” The issue right now is to vote for that party would be – to throw your vote away —— – Exactly. Even if it did really well, if it got 10 percent or 15 percent in, say, Utah, it wouldn’t get any representation. And it might have just made Democrats you really disagree with win the election. But the theory now is that new parties could emerge because getting 20 percent of the vote somewhere is actually enough to begin building a party and have power and maybe get 30 percent next time. And it creates this different dimension of possibility. Yeah. That’s exactly right. But it’s even worse than that. It’s not that you’re throwing away your vote. It’s that that party, you don’t even have the choice of voting for that party, because that party doesn’t exist. Because nobody’s organizing that party, because they know that it is a fool’s errand under our current system.



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Telegram Copy Link

    Related Posts

    Opinions

    Opinion | Trump, the Economy and Work: 10 Gen Z Trump Voters Discuss

    July 16, 2026
    Opinions

    Opinion | Who Will Win the Midterms? Nate Silver and 5 Other Experts Have Thoughts.

    July 13, 2026
    Opinions

    Opinion | Trump and the Democrats: 13 Black Democratic Voters Discuss

    July 8, 2026
    Opinions

    Opinion | 13 George Washington Interpreters on Embodying an Icon

    July 2, 2026
    Opinions

    Opinion | Why Democrats Need a Politics of Joy

    June 23, 2026
    Opinions

    Opinion | The Radical Act of Enjoying This Life

    June 22, 2026
    Editors Picks

    Commentary: Trump’s ultimatum on Ukraine is put to the test by Putin

    August 4, 2025

    UK student loan crisis explained – everything you need to know

    February 26, 2026

    Maple Leafs may have found their next offensive piece

    April 11, 2026

    Commentary: The fragile reopening of Hormuz is no return to normal for Asia

    July 5, 2026

    Opinion | The Three Forces Deranging the Economy in 2025

    December 23, 2025
    About Us
    About Us

    Welcome to Benjamin Franklin Institute, your premier destination for insightful, engaging, and diverse Political News and Opinions.

    The Benjamin Franklin Institute supports free speech, the U.S. Constitution and political candidates and organizations that promote and protect both of these important features of the American Experiment.

    We are passionate about delivering high-quality, accurate, and engaging content that resonates with our readers. Sign up for our text alerts and email newsletter to stay informed.

    Latest Posts

    A High School Dropout Tackled Online Returns — Now Makes $500M

    July 21, 2026

    How a Futurama plotline led to a totally new math proof

    July 21, 2026

    Journey Guitarist Slams Bruce Springsteen as ‘Annoying, Bitter Old Man’ for Turning Concerts into Anti-Trump Political Rallies * The Gateway Pundit * by Cassandra MacDonald

    July 21, 2026

    Subscribe for Updates

    Stay informed by signing up for our free news alerts.

    Paid for by the Benjamin Franklin Institute. Not authorized by any candidate or candidate’s committee.
    • Privacy Policy
    • About us
    • Contact us

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.